First published in 1966, Douglas Haig as I Knew Him is a memoir by G.S. Duncan, a Church of Scotland minister with whom Haig felt such an affinity that he had him transferred to GCHQ. Every Sunday the C-in-C went to the Church of Scotland service to hear him preach.
The book's representation of Haig is unremittingly positive; he is the British commander who rose to new heights with each succeeding crisis & brought us in the end to victory. Duncan writes that he had previously been unwilling to write about a personal relationship with a man who studiously avoided publicity, preferring to devote all his powers to the performance of present duty and to leave the future to be judge of the past. He became aware, however, that in recent years many writers have presented to the public a portrait of Haig which is so distorted as to be essentially false. This personal memoir is therefore designed to redress the balance.
Duncan's reflections on public matters, such as questions of strategy and the conduct of the War are not particularly original. It is the depiction of the private Haig that makes the book worth reading. This is as an undemonstrative, dogged man with a dislike of rhetoric. Duncan is very critical of those who saw Haig's taciturnity as a mark of incoherence or stupidity. Of the backs to the wall order of April 1918, he notes that Haig addressed it to all ranks of the British Forces in France, because he always preferred the inclusive "all ranks" to the alternative "officers and men" and speaks approvingly of the simple straight language which came naturally to him on paper.
The manuscript originally ended with the words "But be of good cheer, the British Empire must win in the end." The words were deleted. Haig was not one to decorate the truth & had a consistently difficult relationship with the Press, whose priorities were different.
This modest book is a succinct view of the man and the war from a unique perspective.Western Front Association
This is a useful view of life in Haig's Headquarters, a much maligned place that is often criticized for being remote from the fighting, and a classic example of the 'chateau' generalship of the First World War. Here we get a view of a hard working and increasingly effective headquarters, which moved closer to the key part of the front on several occasions. Don't expect an unbiased view of Haig - that isn't really the point of this sort of memoir, but do expect a valuable view of Haig from someone who saw him on a regular basis from the Somme in 1916 to the victorious campaigns of 1918.John Rickard - History of War
Read the full review here!
As reviewed on ARRSEARRSE - Lacking Moral Fibre
My only "knowledge" of Haig prior to this was his portrayal by Geoffrey Palmer in Blackadder Goes Forth, and most people I know believe him to have been an unfeeling and uncaring man playing a game of chess with men for pieces. George Duncan, a minister with the Church of Scotland, is better placed than most to give an opinion on Haig. It may be biased, but it's better than anything else we have from a personal point of view.Books Monthly, May 2016 - Paul Norman