Zealous: A Darker Side of the Early Quakers (eBook)

Register or Login now to post a review!

"Erica Canela’s book shows that she is fluent in Quaker language and mores, which many historians are not."

Read the full review here

The Friend

"This is a fine local study of Quakers in a limited geographical area, with close readings of their published writings and meeting Minutes."

Journal of the Friends Historical Society - Vol 76

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

A Bold Look at an Overlooked Story
When most people think of the Quakers, they picture peaceful meetings, quiet prayer, and a reputation for tolerance. But Erica Canela’s Zealous: A Darker Side of the Early Quakers pulls back the curtain to reveal a much more complicated story. Instead of the serene and saintly image often attached to the movement, Canela examines its early fervor, passion, and, at times, unsettling intensity. The result is a history book that both surprises and challenges readers, making us reconsider what we thought we knew about these influential religious figures.

A Journey Into Fierce Convictions
The book traces the earliest days of the Quaker movement, showing how what began as a radical spiritual awakening also carried with it a darker undercurrent of fanaticism and confrontation. Canela doesn’t shy away from describing the aggressive zeal that sometimes defined these communities, nor the social and political disruption they stirred up. Through historical records, vivid storytelling, and careful analysis, she demonstrates how deeply this movement unsettled 17th-century England. Rather than softening the edges of this history, she highlights the raw energy and sometimes troubling fervor that drove early Quakers forward.

Refreshing Honesty in Historical Storytelling
What stands out most in Canela’s writing is her balance between rigorous research and accessible prose. The book doesn’t feel weighed down by heavy academic jargon, yet it never skimps on detail. Her descriptions make the past feel immediate, and she has a knack for bringing out the personalities behind the movement, showing them as flawed but fascinating human beings. By grounding the narrative in both historical fact and human emotion, she makes the story approachable for readers who may not usually gravitate toward religious history. It’s a refreshing take that keeps the pages turning.

More Than Just a Religious History
While Zealous is certainly a book about faith, it is equally about power, society, and the risks that come with fervent belief. Canela places the Quakers within their broader historical context, reminding us that movements are never isolated—they are always in dialogue with the world around them. Readers get to see how these early Quakers influenced politics, culture, and even the way religion itself evolved in the modern age. It’s a reminder that history is never as tidy as we might like to imagine, and that even movements born in peace can have sharp and surprising edges.

A Book That Lingers After Reading
In the end, Canela’s Zealous is an eye-opening and deeply engaging book that lingers in the mind long after the last page. By exploring the overlooked complexities of the Quakers’ origins, she adds nuance to a subject too often painted in broad strokes. It’s a book that invites both reflection and conversation, making it a worthwhile read for history buffs, religious scholars, and anyone curious about the hidden sides of familiar stories. Rather than diminishing the Quakers, Canela’s work enriches our understanding of them, proving that even the darker chapters of history can shed light on human resilience and belief.

NetGalley, Amanda Sedlak-Hevener

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

It is a great microhistory. The intellectual and social development of a religion is great stuff.

NetGalley, Logan Kedzie

Zealous is a fascinating and eye-opening exploration of the lesser-known, more intense aspects of early Quaker history. Erica Canela presents her research in a way that is both thorough and engaging, bringing to light conflicts, fervor, and human complexity that often get overlooked in standard histories of the movement...

Overall, it’s a compelling read for anyone interested in religious history, early American culture, or the complexities behind seemingly peaceful movements.

NetGalley, Moira Frederickson

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

This book was extremely interesting and well researched. I will be looking for more books by this author. Would definitely recommend!

NetGalley, Rebecca Stewart

Dr. Canela's dedication and meticulous research into this topic shines through.

NetGalley, Julia Shipton

From Darkness comes Light. Erica Canela, in a model combination of scholarship and readability, explains how Quakerism emerged from the traumas of a world turned upside down in the British Isles in the 1640s and 1650s.

Thomas Hamm, Emeritus Professor of History, Earlham College. Author of The Quakers in America

Zealous is a fascinating examination of early Quakers in Herefordshire and Worcestershire. Canela’s highly readable and engaging account reveals the critical role of regional politics and circumstances in shaping local expressions and experiences of Quakerism.

Robynne Rogers Healey, Professor of History, Trinity Western University

Erica Canela has written the best account we have of the emerging Quaker movement and its social context in two midlands counties: a book at once both lively and authoritative.

Stephen K. Roberts, History of Parliament Trust, London

Ambitious in its intent, and masterful in its execution. In Zealous, Canela has unearthed a hidden story in the most engaging and informative of ways!

Jackson van Uden, History with Jackson & BBC History Extra '30 under 30'

A vivid and groundbreaking account of how the early Quakers defied seventeenth century norms to forge a lasting spiritual revolution.

Estelle Paranque, Author of Thorns, Lust and Glory: The Betrayal of Anne Boleyn

In Zealous, Dr. Erica Canela vividly unpacks the origins of the Quaker movement, which emerged from the ashes of a brutal civil war. In a shattered nation where crown and church had been pulled down, the Quakers forged a new spiritual path to fill the resulting void. Far from being peace-seeking souls, this radical group tapped into widespread unrest and anxiety to incite followers. Their mission was to make sense of the chaos they had endured, take control, and create a viable religious belief system for those coping with the trauma of war. With clarity and energy, Zealous traces the rise of the Quakers through key figures like George Fox, Margaret Fell, and James Nayler, while also shining a light on the everyday men and women who shaped the movement - particularly in Worcestershire and Herefordshire. Insightful and engaging, this balanced account brings their convictions and struggles to life, while revealing the bold, disruptive strategies these spiritual revolutionaries employed to achieve their ends.

Mark Turnbull, Author of Prince Rupert of the Rhine: King Charles I's Cavalier Commander

This is a good local study to fill out our existing national history of early Quakerism, with some additional and moving perspectives not found in previous scholarship.

Professor Ronald Hutton CBE, Author of Oliver Cromwell: Commander in Chief